Back to Editorials
The Indian ExpressJuly 10, 2026

In Thane, seen again, the rowdy Shiv Sainik. Sena does well to act against him

The Shiv Sena (Eknath Shinde) has done the right thing in admonishing its corporator, Ramesh Mhatre, for theassault on doctors and medical staff of a Thane municipal hospitalafter a video of the incident went viral. The altercation reportedly arose over the treatment of a patient on Monday. At times, tempers do run high in hospitals with patients and their families contending with overcrowded, and often unhygienic, facilities. But Mhatre’s conduct is reprehensible not only because it’s an assault on medical professionals but also an abuse of his official position. Residents approach their municipal representatives over a host of everyday civic concerns. Their effectiveness lies in responding with empathy, escalating complaints for redressal, and demanding public accountability. A corporator should never intimidate or browbeat officials when they are discharging their duties. Mhatre’s arrest on Wednesday has, therefore, sent the right message — Maharashtra’s Mahayuti government, of which the Shinde Sena is a part, will not treat high-handedness with impunity. For at least three decades since its formation in 1966, the Shiv Sena cultivated a politics that was seen to encourage direct action even at the cost of transgressing the rule of law. While upholding Marathi pride was the party’s avowed objective, parochialism often slipped into shows of force and violence. Whether in enforcing bandhs, intervening in local disputes or confronting officials, the Sena projected itself as an organisation willing to bypass institutions in favour of a rough politics. However, as the party assumed greater responsibilities in government, it sought to present itself as a mature political outfit capable of administering complex public institutions. Shiv Sainiks, though, have not completely abandoned their ways of yore. After the party split in 2022, cadres loyal to Uddhav Thackeray reportedly vandalised the offices of the rival Shinde faction. In March last year, workers of the Shinde Sena ransacked aMumbaiauditorium, where comedian Kunal Kamra had taken a jibe against their leader. The Mahayuti government, which often makes developmental initiatives its calling card, can ill afford to allow such acts of intimidation to become normalised. It must ensure that Wednesday’s action is not an isolated response but the standard for dealing with the abuse of political power.

Key GK Takeaways for CLAT
  • 1This episode implicates the constitutional and statutory duties of elected municipal representatives under the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992, which established Urban Local Bodies like municipal corporations as constitutional entities under Part IXA of the Constitution, with corporators expected to function within codified civic roles rather than through personal intimidation. The editorial's emphasis on institutional accountability over direct action reflects the broader constitutional vision of local self-government as a deliberative, rule-bound tier of governance.
  • 2Domestically, this reflects a recurring policy challenge for the Mahayuti coalition government in Maharashtra, comprising the Shinde Shiv Sena, the BJP, and the Ajit Pawar NCP faction, which must balance internal party discipline against its public image of administrative maturity ahead of future civic body elections in the state. Political parties governing through coalition arrangements often face reputational spillover from individual members' conduct, complicating collective accountability.
  • 3Legally, assault on hospital staff performing public duties can attract charges under provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 analogous to the former Section 353 IPC for obstructing public servants, and separately, several states including Maharashtra have enacted specific Medicare Service Persons and Medicare Service Institutions (Prevention of Violence) Acts to criminalise violence against doctors, reflecting a dedicated legal-regulatory response to a nationally recurring problem of hospital violence. The 2022 Shiv Sena split itself generated significant Tenth Schedule anti-defection jurisprudence before the Supreme Court in the Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra line of proceedings.
  • 4Violence against healthcare workers is a documented public health and economic concern: the Indian Medical Association has cited surveys suggesting over 75 percent of doctors in India have faced some form of violence at their workplace, contributing to defensive medicine practices and rising healthcare delivery costs. This context underscores why the editorial treats what might seem a localised Thane incident as symptomatic of a wider governance and public-safety issue worth national editorial attention.